Crisis in Stilfontein: Hundreds of Illegal Miners Remain Trapped Underground Amid Crackdown

Stilfontein, South Africa – A crisis is unfolding as hundreds of illegal miners, known locally as “zama zamas,” remain trapped deep underground in an abandoned mine shaft in Stilfontein, North West Province. Authorities have cut off essential supplies such as food and water in an attempt to coerce the miners to surface, sparking significant concerns over their wellbeing and igniting heated debates around human rights and mining practices.

Tense Standoff Between Police and Miners

The situation escalated when police halted the supply of food, water, and medication to the miners, some of whom have been underground for months. According to police spokesperson Athlenda Mathe, the decision to restrict these supplies aims to force the miners to come to the surface, stating, “We are stopping and preventing food and water to go down there as a way of forcing these illegal miners to resurface because what they are doing is criminal.”

Yet, the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) has voiced strong concerns over the potential loss of lives due to the measures taken by law enforcement. “We are currently investigating the situation to determine whether cutting off supplies violates the miners’ basic human rights,” the commission noted in a statement on Friday.

Harsh Conditions Underground

The miners, estimated to number between several hundred to potentially up to 4,000 according to some reports, are enduring extreme conditions. Without food and water for several months, the health of those underground is believed to be deteriorating rapidly. Reports indicate that they face severe dehydration, starvation, and exposure to toxic dust, which has sparked fears of a mass casualty situation if the standoff continues.

David Van Wyk, a senior researcher at the Johannesburg-based Benchmarks Foundation, expressed grave concerns over the miners’ condition. “At this point, they are starving, becoming dehydrated, and breathing toxic dust. When they come out, they’re likely to be extremely weak and sick,” he said.

The Community’s Reaction

Relatives of the trapped miners have gathered near the mine shaft, anxiously awaiting any signs of their loved ones resurfacing. Ntomboxolo Qwanti, a woman whose husband has been underground for eight months, told reporters, “We are here for our brothers and sisters. We are desperate for news and fear the worst.”

Community activist Meshack Mbangula, head of the Mining Affected Communities United in Action (MACUA), emphasized that the miners’ predicament is a direct consequence of systemic failures in the mining industry. “If the abandoned mines had been properly closed as required by law, we wouldn’t have thousands risking their lives in these shafts,” he argued.

The Roots of the Crisis

The issue of illegal mining in South Africa runs deep, with an estimated 100,000 artisanal miners operating in disused shafts across the country. These “zama zamas” often work under dangerous conditions, extracting minerals that are sold on the black market. Despite the risks, many miners feel they have no choice but to continue this work due to unemployment and poverty.

Van Wyk highlighted how the closure of large-scale mining operations has exacerbated the problem. “Thousands of retrenched workers from these abandoned sites have no alternative means of making a living. They go back to the mines because it’s the only skill they have,” he explained.

Calls for Policy Change

The South African Federation of Trade Unions (SAFTU) and other advocacy groups have criticized the government’s approach, calling it inhumane. SAFTU’s statement described the police’s measures as “a vindictive act” that risks leading to a tragic outcome. The union emphasized that “cutting off food and water supplies without engaging with these mineworkers directly or indirectly is counterproductive and harmful.”

Mbangula of MACUA called for reforms, suggesting that legalizing artisanal mining and implementing safety measures could turn the sector into a legitimate source of employment. “If artisanal mining is decriminalized and regulated, it could create jobs and contribute to reducing crime and poverty,” he argued.

Government’s Stance and Future Outlook

South African government officials have taken a firm stance on the situation. Minister in the Presidency, Khumbudzo Ntshavheni, reaffirmed that no assistance would be provided to those underground, labeling them as criminals. “We are not sending help to criminals. We are going to smoke them out,” Ntshavheni said, drawing criticism from some quarters who argue that such rhetoric criminalizes individuals who are often driven by poverty and desperation.

Mametlwe Sebei, leader of the General Industries Workers Union of South Africa, warned that such hardline approaches could worsen the humanitarian crisis. “This kind of response neglects the social and economic factors that push people into illegal mining. We must tackle the root causes instead,” he commented.

As the situation develops, police and defense officials are expected to visit the site, reinforcing their commitment to a lawful resolution. Community-led rescue attempts are also being organized but require indemnification from the authorities before proceeding.

The Broader Implications

This crisis underscores the broader challenges South Africa faces in regulating its mining industry. The existence of around 6,000 abandoned and unsecured mines creates fertile ground for illegal mining activities. Without a sustainable strategy for closure and rehabilitation, the problem is likely to persist, experts warn.

Until systemic issues such as unemployment, poverty, and corporate accountability are addressed, the desperation that drives individuals underground will remain a significant challenge for South African society.